Innova DX vs Champion Starter Set: Is the Premium Plastic Worth $10 More?
Innova DX Starter Set (Leopard/Shark/Aviar, $25–$32) vs Champion Starter Set (Valkyrie/Panther/Aviar, $37): different discs, not just plastic. Which beginner buys which.
This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
Table of contents
Innova sells two three-disc starter sets, and the way they’re named — DX and Champion — makes it sound like the same three discs in a cheap plastic and a premium one. They aren’t. The plastics differ, but so do two of the three discs, and the disc difference matters more to a beginner than the plastic does. This comparison lays out exactly what’s in each box, what DX and Champion plastic actually do over time, and which set fits which player.
We haven’t thrown these sets side by side for this article. It’s built from Innova’s published flight numbers and descriptions for each mold, retailer listings and prices (Infinite Discs and Amazon, September 2026), and owner reviews and forum consensus on how each mold and plastic behaves for new players.
| Product | Our rating | Discs included | Plastic | Typical weights | Skill ceiling | Price | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best first set Innova DX Disc Golf Starter Set | 4.5/5 | Leopard (6/5/−2/1), Shark (4/4/0/2), Aviar (2/3/0/1) | DX (base) | 160–175 g | Beginner → intermediate | $20–$32 | Check Price |
| Best premium-plastic set Innova Champion Starter Set | 4.0/5 | Valkyrie (9/4/−2/2), Panther (5/4/−2/1), Aviar (2/3/0/1) | Champion (premium) | 165–175 g | Beginner+ → intermediate | $35–$57 | Check Price |
Head-to-head
| DX Starter Set | Champion Starter Set | |
|---|---|---|
| Driver | Leopard — fairway, 6 / 5 / −2 / 1, 1.6 cm rim | Valkyrie — distance, 9 / 4 / −2 / 2, 1.9 cm rim |
| Midrange | Shark — 4 / 4 / 0 / 2 | Panther — 5 / 4 / −2 / 1, 1.3 cm shallow rim |
| Putter | Aviar — 2 / 3 / 0 / 1 | Aviar — 2 / 3 / 0 / 1 |
| Plastic | DX (base) | Champion (premium, “up to 5× longer” life per Innova) |
| Typical weights | 160–175 g (varies by batch) | 165–175 g |
| Price | $25–$32 | $35–$40 |
| Availability | Everywhere, always | Periodically out of stock |
Sources: Innova — Leopard, Valkyrie, Panther; Innova starter set page; Infinite Discs — Champion Starter Set.
The discs: Leopard vs Valkyrie is the whole decision
Start with the driver, because it decides who each set is for.
The DX set’s Leopard is a speed-6 fairway driver with −2 turn: it reaches its designed speed with a beginner’s arm and flies straight, then fades gently. Innova calls it “everyone’s first fairway driver,” and our Leopard review explains why the whole sport agrees.
The Champion set’s Valkyrie is a speed-9 distance driver. Innova describes it as “a turnover distance driver with great glide” and lists it as a “first distance driver” — which is accurate, but a first distance driver is a disc for someone who already throws a fairway driver well. Thrown by a true beginner, a Valkyrie doesn’t reach its speed: it fades early, lands short-left, and teaches nothing. Thrown by a player with 200–250 ft of power, it’s a very good disc and noticeably longer than a Leopard.
The mids are closer. The DX Shark (4/4/0/2) is the more forgiving of the two — stable, with enough fade to teach what a reliable finish looks like. The Champion Panther (5/4/−2/1) is understable with a shallow 1.3 cm rim, which suits small hands and produces controlled turnover shots; new in stiff Champion plastic it flies a little straighter than its −2 suggests. Neither is a wrong choice.
The Aviar is the same mold in both sets and the disc you’ll keep longest. Our Aviar review covers it; in Champion it’s stiffer and lasts years, in DX it’s grippier and $9.
The plastic: what DX and Champion actually do
DX is Innova’s base plastic. It’s cheap and grippy — many players prefer its feel for putters — and it’s soft enough that trees, rocks and ground scrapes change a disc’s flight within a season, almost always toward more understable. For a beginner that’s a quiet advantage: a DX Leopard that has hit a few trees turns over more easily and becomes a great turnover and roller disc. The cost is that you’ll replace it, and at $9 that’s fine.
Champion is a stiff, translucent premium plastic. Innova’s claim is up to five times the life of DX, and owners broadly agree that Champion discs fly the same for years. Two things beginners should know: Champion runs slightly more stable than DX when new — the Panther and Valkyrie will feel less friendly out of the box than their numbers suggest — and it’s slick when wet. For a putter you’ll throw for years, Champion is a clear win. For a driver you’ll outgrow in a season, it’s paying for durability you won’t use.
What owners of each set report
The DX set has years of reviews and the pattern is settled: praise for the Leopard and Aviar, a shrug at the Shark’s fade, and the one recurring complaint that DX wears fast — which most reviewers then say they didn’t mind at the price. Newer players describe the Leopard as the first disc they threw straight.
The Champion set has far fewer reviews as a set, and the ones that exist split by who’s writing. Players with some experience praise the value — three Champion discs for under $40 — and the Aviar. Newer players are the ones who mention the Valkyrie fading early or feeling “heavy,” which is a speed problem, not a plastic problem. A few note the Panther felt straighter than expected out of the box, which is Champion’s extra stiffness; it loosens up.
Read together, the reviews say what the spec sheets say: the DX set is the better first set, and the Champion set is the better second one.
Price and availability
The DX set is $25–$32 and stocked everywhere, always. The Champion set is $35–$40 — about $10 more, which for three premium discs is a good deal — but it drifts in and out of stock at the big retailers and has few reviews as a set because most players buy Champion discs individually. If you can’t find it, three Champion discs bought separately (Aviar, Panther, Leopard3 instead of the Valkyrie) come to about $50 and are arguably the better set anyway.
Which one should you buy?
Buy the DX set if:
- It’s your first disc golf set, full stop.
- You can’t yet throw a fairway driver 200 ft.
- You want the cheapest way to find out whether you like the sport.
- You’d rather replace a $9 disc than baby a $15 one.
Buy the Champion set if:
- You’ve played a few rounds and can get a fairway driver 200+ ft, or you throw hard from another sport.
- You play wooded courses and want discs that survive trees.
- You want a putter you’ll never replace.
- Your DX set has gone flippy and you want the next step in one box.
Consider building your own — DX set plus a Champion Aviar, or three Champion discs with a Leopard3 in place of the Valkyrie — if you want the best of both. Our first disc golf set guide covers the mix-and-match approach, and the disc types guide explains why a speed-9 driver is the wrong first disc.
Our pick
For almost everyone reading a “starter set” comparison, the DX set, and it isn’t close: the Leopard is the right first driver and the Valkyrie isn’t, and the durability of Champion plastic is worth nothing on a disc you’ll want to replace within a season anyway. The Champion set is a good buy for the specific player who already has some arm and wants discs that last — but that player is usually better served buying three Champion discs of their own choosing. Whichever you pick, the Aviar is the keeper, and the DX Leopard’s short life ends with a Leopard3 or Teebird, which is the natural next purchase either way. For how Innova’s sets stack up against Discraft’s and Dynamic Discs’, see our best beginner sets roundup.
How we evaluated this gear
We have not physically tested every product on this page. Ratings are based on manufacturer specifications, PDGA-approved flight data, and hundreds of aggregated owner reviews and community discussions (r/discgolf, retailer reviews, club forums). Where we describe how something "feels" or "flies", that reflects the consensus of experienced players, not a lab test. We update ratings when the consensus changes.